Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Becoming More Media Literature While Working on Other Skills

The drama unit I teach my English II Honors involves reading Antigone and Taming of the Shrew, two classic texts very entrenched in the time period in which they were written. The culture of both of these eras is fascinating and also very well reflected in the texts themselves. There is so much historical information I could cover here, but it would mean a lot of lecturing on my part. Instead, I break the history down into 24 topics (12 about Ancient Greece and 12 about the Elizabethan era). The students work in partners or alone (their choice) with one of these 24 topics, and they must do the research, decide what’s most interesting/relevant, and present it to the class.

Last year, I had them do this project using Microsoft PowerPoint. Well, let me tell you that the students already know PowerPoint backwards and forwards. They have seen plenty of PowerPoints, and they have created plenty of PowerPoints. This just isn’t anything new for them.

With this in mind (inspired by this grad class’s discussions), this year, they had to think of a different way to present their information for this particular assignment. I showed them some options including Prezi, and it was up to them to figure out what they wanted to use and how it could best be used so long as they covered their important information and had MLA citations. I’m not going to lie: some of their technical frustrations seemed epic. However, I truly believe they grew through this assignment on more levels than my students last year. Working through the new technology forced them to work on those ever-important media literacy skills while working on research and presentation skills.

A flexible literacy

I taught my first high school class today - I was invited in to teach poetry on the narrative of immigration. And it was amazing! But something that really struck me while I was debriefing with the English teacher was how textual literacy is really about more than making literal sense of the words on the page or the words you're hearing. It's also about developing a flexibility - to accept that there are multiple meanings that can lay beneath the surface of a text. It was something that many of the students really struggled with - they wanted there to be a single RIGHT answer. We didn't talk very directly about applications of various understandings of literacies in more traditional settings - how we encourage a flexible sort of literacy as we help students develop more technical literacies skills.

The English teacher had assigned a final project for the students that challenged them to find the right medium in which to express an immigrant's personal experience (they are doing a group interview). That's an incredible kind of media flexibility that I really hope the students take advantage of that and create pieces that explore the ambiguous ways we communicate with each other.

Keeping up with Technology through Constant Budget Cuts

Recent articles I have been seeing over the past few months have prompted me to think a lot about this week’s BB Post on looking to the future of media literacy and technology. In my BB Post on this topic I discussed how one challenge I can see with emerging technology and media tools is simply trying to keep up and stay on top of the latest trends. New tools and tech trends are constantly emerging, and keeping up with the volume of tools, gadgets, programs, and so on is a tough task. How do we decide which trends are the best to focus on? Which will benefit our students and patrons the most? Which ones are worth putting our time and energy into? However, another challenge we are facing right now with media literacy and technology is where to get the funding to keep technology up to date and media literacy programs going.

On a weekly basis I see headlines stating that library budgets are being cut, that schools don’t have the funding to buy new materials for their libraries, or that school librarian positions are being cut. Just this morning I read an article about a school district in Portland Oregon that is letting go of 25 of their 50 school librarians in order to cut 26 million dollars from its budget. (http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/slj/home/890421-312/beaverton__or_schools_may.html.csp)
With school districts and libraries struggling with budget issues around the country, how on earth are library professionals supposed to keep up with technology trends and make sure they are preparing their students for a more and more heavily media driven world? Media literacy is a top priority right now in school curriculums. It is imperative that schools are instructing their students in technology and media tools so that they will have the competencies needed to function in a professional world that is becoming more focused and reliant on technology and media. However, how are we supposed to accomplish this when we don’t have the funding, tools, or even professionals to pass on these skills and knowledge?

School Library Journal’s 2011 Technology Survey shows that while school librarians are positive about technology and the future, many admit that their schools are behind when it comes to technology. Obstacles such as “poor funding, lack of time, and unsupportive administrators,” are keeping them from staying on top of media literacy and technology. For instance, while ebooks in school libraries are growing, 63 % of librarians surveyed report that their libraries cannot afford ereader devices. The survey responses show that most school librarians are excited about ereaders and ebooks, and would love to try them out in their libraries, but they just do not have the funding to do so. With schools facing drastic budget cuts, library funds are one of the first to go. (http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/slj/home/890197-312/sljs_2011_technology_survey_things.html.csp)

On March 3rd, 2011, Brian Kenney responded to the SLJ 2011 Tech Survey with an article stating that the survey “reveals vast inequities in our nation’s libraries.” (http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/slj/printissuecurrentissue/890155-427/story.csp) In the survey some schools reported being “cutting edge” and “up to date” with technology, however, Kenney explains that these schools are “more the exception than the rule.” Kenney says the survey results pinpointed three major themes schools face in relation to technology and media literacy. The first is what he calls the “digital divide.” Many urban and rural schools do not have the funding to incorporate technology into their school, and very few of their students have access to computers and technology at home as well. Because of this students are not being exposed to technology, and most are not media literate. Kenney goes on to say that “the only federal program that helps alleviate some of this inequity, Improving Literacy Through School Libraries, won’t be funded in FY2011—for the first time in a decade.”

The second theme Kenney saw emerging from the survey is a “digital slide.” Schools in the digital slide have access to technology, but it is out of date, and due to funding issues may not be replaced for some time. Teachers in this category report that while their school was once up to date with technology and media literacy, budget cuts have kept them from keeping up with emerging tools and technology. These teachers explain that because the resources and tools they have are out of date, they are not able to use them for teaching.

The last theme Kenney discusses is the “digital tide.” This is when classrooms are technologically up to date and have the latest tools and programs, however the budget has not allowed the library to be updated as well. In the SLJ survey, many schools reported that any funding available is delegated to classroom use first, leaving the library with little money to work with. Because of this it is difficult for school libraries to meet media literacy standards.

Kenney states that “underfunding technology doesn’t make it harder for librarians to do their jobs—it makes it impossible.” When schools are not able to stay up to date with technology, they are not able to teach students information and media literacy skills, which are now heavily focused on learning standards across the country. The American Association of School Librarians’ Standards for the 21st-Century Learner are centered around technology, media, and information literacy. (http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/aasl/guidelinesandstandards/learningstandards/AASL_LearningStandards.pdf) The AASL Standards state that “ technology skills are crucial for future employment needs. Today’s students need to develop information skills that will enable them to use technology as an important tool for learning, both now and in the future.” In addition, the AASL Standards stress that all students should have equitable access to information and information technology, however, as the SLJ survey points out, this is not happening. With budget cuts and funding issues students educational needs are not being met and curriculum standards are not being adhered to.

Why is it that when the budget gets rocky the library is the first thing to take a hit? As the AASL Standards point out, the School Library Media Center is where so many of todays curriculum standards should be addressed and met, so why are are school libraries lacking materials and tools, and why are our Media Specialist the first to be cut? If we want to make media and information literacy a priority, and want our students to be prepared for their future, we need to put more focus on school libraries and keeping them equiped and up to date to meet student needs. As we have discussed in class, technology isn’t going anywhere, if anything it is coming more rapidly than ever, so we need to prepare our school libraries and professionals in order to provide our students with the best opportunities we can.

Kenney, Brian. “SLJ’s 2011 Technology Survey: Things are Changing. Fast.” School Library Journal. May 1, 2011. http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/slj/printissuecurrentissue/890197-427/sljs_2011_technology_survey_things.html.csp


Kenney, Brian. “Not Just the Lucky Ones.” School Library Journal. May 1, 2011.
http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/slj/printissuecurrentissue/890155-427/story.csp

American Association of School Librarians. “Standards for the 21st- Century Learner.”

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Music + Teens = Depression or Depression + Teens = Music?

I just came across an excerpt of this article in a magazine last week and thought it was worth discussing. The article from NPR.org (http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2011/04/06/135151133/what-comes-first-depression-in-teens-or-emo-music) discusses that teens are more likely to be depressed if they listen to a lot of music. On the contrary, students who read a lot are less likely to be depressed. The study was done by researchers at the University of Pittsburgh.

It almost seemed to be sort of a "which came first, the chicken or the egg?" type question when determining whether depressed kids tended to listen to music more, or kids who listened to music more tended to be depressed. While this was not the main focus of the study, the lead researcher stated that it was more likely that depressed teens listened to music for comfort, rather than music making kids depressed.

I did not realize that nearly ten percent of teens suffered from depression. Earlier assumptions were that depressed teens watched more tv; however, the study showed a much stronger correlation between depressed teens and music, rather than tv. Researchers attributed the lower rate of depression among avid readers to the fact that reading is more engaging for the brain, to the extent that depressed teens may not have the energy to engage their brain at that level.

I found it really interesting to apply this finding anecdotally to some of my students. I found that the more that I thought about it, I tended to agree with the findings. My students that often try to listen to music constantly do sometimes tend to be more withdrawn than others, which would be a major sign of possible depression. Having said that, one of the more severally depressed students that I have had over the years read constantly which definitely goes against the finding of this study. Obviously the study is not without exception as you might expect.

Overall, I did find it quite interesting and I am going to be more watchful of student behavior and add this to my bag of tricks in trying to help my students to the extent that I can.

Moving the Message: "It Gets Better"

Something amazing happened tonight. Despite the fact that I had recorded "Glee" on my DVR and was able to skip through every single commercial that aired, I literally stopped and rewound to watch this commerical for Google Chrome:



Mary Anne has already talked about Dan Savage's "It Gets Better" campaign, so I won't go too much into it other than to say that it is a message that many teens, especially those struggling to accept or be accepted in their sexuality, needed to hear.

This commercial, which ends with the tagline, “the web is what you make of it”, shows a sort of timeline of this movement, beginning with articles written in the New York Times about the suicides of a number of gay teens – one article calling it an “epidemic” – and ends with the comments that are being left on the It Gets Better website from teens and others who have been moved by the message.


The thing that struck me about this commercial was how Google demonstrated how someone can take action and have their cause and message spread far and wide via today’s social media tools. What started as a YouTube video of Dan and his partner, Terry, explaining how they, too, had had a difficult time as gay high school students has grown to include videos from the likes of Woody from “Toy Story” assuring the viewer that, “You’ll be fine, partner”.


I loved this commercial – for its message and its content. It was truly inspiring and empowering to behold. It stopped me in my DVR tracks.


The 12 New Media Literacies - From Project New Media Literacies (PNML)

I came across a website for a program called Project New Media Literacies, which is hosted by USC-Annenberg. One of directors is Henry Jenkins, who happens to be one of my favorite scholars in this field. While looking through the website, I found a page describing these "new media literacies," and I really enjoyed the breakdown they gave. I've included the original content below (in black text) and my comments on each literacy (in blue text).

The New Media Literacies constitute the core cultural competencies and social skills that young people need in our new media landscape. We call them "literacies," but they change the focus of literacy from one of individual expression to one of community involvement. They build on the foundation of traditional literacy, research skills, technical skills, and critical analysis skills taught in the classroom. If these New Media Literacies are learned - and they can be learned without computers in the classroom - they can form the building blocks for students' participation in new media. 

Play: the capacity to experiment with one's surroundings as a form of problem-solving. Having a strong sense of play can be helpful when you pick up a new piece of technology that you've never used before, when you're trying to write an essay and your outline isn't functioning as you'd hoped, and when you're designing anything at all, from a dress to a web page to a concert's program.

I love the idea of "play" because it really is the best way to learn something. I suppose it could be called a number of things--like tinkering, perhaps?--but it really does work. After all, one of the best ways to learn how to do something is to actually do it. There has to be a feeling of almost fearlessness with this--as in you have to play with something and not be terrified that you're going to mess something up. When I was teaching, this was one of the most commonly cited reasons I heard from teachers who didn't want to try out new things. Luckily, I think I'm sort of naturally drawn towards this behavior. When I received my first computer in 8th grade (this was in 1993), I knew little about computers and my family members knew even less. I basically just messed with it until it worked, and I've continued to do that with anything new that comes my way. Thus, it is important that we give students the opportunity to play and build these skills.

Performance: the ability to adopt alternative identities for the purpose of improvisation and discovery. Being able to move fluidly and effectively between roles can help you when you're exploring online communities, when you're trying to decide what actions are ethical, and when you're shuffling between home, work and school.

This is also extremely important and is relevant to the online world, and the real world as well. Students need to understand audience, and that they need to take on different "personas" and know who and what they're dealing with to effectively navigate and communicate in a variety of situations.

Simulation: the ability to interpret and construct dynamic models of real-world processes. Being able to interpret, manipulate and create simulations can help you understand innumerable complex systems, like ecologies and computer networks - and make you better at playing video games!

I think this one can be a little more difficult to learn and to also helps students with; however, as is mentioned in the introduction, computers aren't necessarily needed for students to learn how to do this. The right assignment/problem and a little posterboard, even, can get students moving in the right direction. Then, as they pick up even more skills, they can move on to more complex ways of building these simulations.

Appropriation: the ability to meaningfully sample and remix media content. Being able to remix media content (and knowing when doing so is appropriate) can help you understand literary works, music, and art; it can also help lead you to a deeper understanding of copyright and cultural clashes.

This is something that we are seeing more and more of in schools, but it is not always done correctly. Students can have a lot of fun with and get a lot out of these types of projects, but teachers and librarians need to be well-informed of copyright laws in order to help students use this content correctly. We have to know these things so that we can hold students accountable--which is also a learning experience for them.

Multitasking: the ability to scan one's environment and shift focus as needed to salient details. Being a good multitasker is required in our new media landscape - and that includes learning when it isn't good to multitask.

This is such an important skill for everyone to have, and I'll admit it was difficult for me to latch onto when I started teaching--but as many of you know, you have to be able to multi-task as a teacher to stay organized and sane! From what I've seen with a lot of students, many think they are good at multi-tasking because they "Facebook," listen to music, watch YouTube videos, and write papers all at the same time; however, this is not so. Effectively multi-tasking also means that you have a keen understanding of setting and adhering to priorities--and like I mentioned before, this can be very difficult for some people. Also, as is mentioned, sometimes it isn't good to multitask.

Distributed Cognition: the ability to interact meaningfully with tools that expand mental capacities. That can mean something as simple as using a ruler or calculator, or something as complex as efficiently using Wikipedia on your iPhone to access information on the fly.

Again, this goes back to that issue of play and giving students the tools to learn from. The hope is, of course, that students learn the skills so that they can apply these to all the new and different tools that will come their way. 

Collective Intelligence: the ability to pool knowledge and compare notes with others toward a common goal. This ability is key to open source projects. Being able to pool knowledge with others can allow us to solve challenges far more complex than the individual mind can process.

And students wonder why they're assigned group projects! It is essential that students learn to harness collective intelligence when analyzing and solving problems. In order for this to happen, though, they need to be given assignments that truly challenge them to work together and analyze. Far too often I've seen group projects assigned that require little to no critical thinking, and then one person ends up doing all the work. Students will rise to the challenge if given something meaningful to work on.

Judgment: the ability to evaluate the reliability and credibility of different information sources. If you're worried about your students using Wikipedia at inappropriate times and taking everything they read on the internet as gospel truth, you're worried that they aren't exercising good judgment. But judgment also includes knowing when sources are appropriate for your use: for instance, sometimes Wikipedia might be the appropriate resource to use. 

This is also so important, and I love that they've used Wikipedia as an example! This was something I tried to hammer into the heads of my students. Time and time again I told them that Wikipedia is fine for a starting place, to get some basic information, or to settle a feud about some trivial pop culture reference. It is not, however, the best source when writing a serious literary analysis.

Transmedia Navigation: the ability to follow the flow of stories and information across multiple media. Anyone who needs to do research needs a good understanding of transmedia navigation - how to follow threads through video, still photography, written work, music, online sources etc.

We are seeing more and more of this from adults and students alike. As I mentioned in my last blog post, just look at how quickly the news spread of Osama bin Laden's death. My guess is that a lot of people sort of naturally navigated through different types of media--from comments on Facebook, to news stories, to TV, to videos posted, to Google images and more.

Networking -- the ability to search for, synthesize, and disseminate information. Writing something isn't enough without the ability to circulate it to the communities where it will matter.

This adds a whole other dimension to the word networking, and this is something that all of us have brought up time and time again during our discussions of different types of media and how to become media literate. It's finding, analyzing, creating--all of that--and then getting it to the right audience.

Negotiation -- the ability to travel across diverse communities, discerning and respecting multiple perspectives, and grasping and following alternative norms. We now need to know how to live in multiple communities - from the hyperlocal to the global and from those composed of people like us to those consisting of people very different from us.

This is basically respecting diversity and understanding your place in the world, realizing that you have only one perspective out of many, and respecting the perspectives of others. Now that is so easy to have a voice online, it's important for students and adults to practice this and strive for this constantly.

Visualization - the ability to translate information into visual models and understand the information visual models are communicating. VIsualization has become a key way we cope with large data sets and make sense of the complexity of our environment.

This is something we've talked about in class--that ability and skill to create--and that it is a form of communicating. Just like talking or writing a paper, creating a video and sharing it with the world is also a form of communication. This is why it's important for students to have opportunities to create, share, and receive feedback from a real audience. When students are creating for real people, it puts a whole new spin on things and is a good learning experience for them.

If you'd like to read more about Project New Media Literacies, check it out at http://www.newmedialiteracies.org/.

First Attempt

Over the past week, I've had an opportunity to give my Presentation Wiki a "test run." To recap: for my final project, I created a wiki which is intended to be the basis for presenting a session at the Illinois School Library Media Association fall conference. The wiki introduces the advantages of using wikis in the library, and introduces several Web 2.0 tools that are easy to use with wikis and gives ideas for how librarians might use those tools. A few weeks ago, my district decided to pay any willing staff to create and present "in-house" professional development opportunities. So I offered to teach a 3-session workshop on wikis and using Web 2.0 tools in the classroom. The workshops finished today.
I must say that I am very glad to have had an opportunity to debut this presentation before I attempted to give it at a conference! I learned that I need to make sure that I am defining any "techy" terms, and that I shouldn't assume any prior knowledge. At times I was taken aback by my colleagues' lack of computer skills: I taught one person how to take a screen shot, another worried that she wouldn't be able to use Prezi because she "didn't even know how to use PowerPoint" yet. I taught another how to navigate to various drives in order to upload (I have no idea how she uses a digital camera!) to the wiki.
Top three aspects I would change if I were to give this workshop again:


  1. Have a handout with all web addresses and log-ins spelled out.

  2. Make a separate wiki just for this presentation for faculty...I used the one intended for librarians and although it was nice to debut it, I'd prefer to present something custom-made for the audience.

  3. Make more examples/find more examples of student projects.
Top three aspects that I think worked well during this workshop:


  1. I taught wiki-use on the first day, then introduced 3 Web 2.0 tools on the second day, and 3 on the third day. This was a good way to break up the sessions. Participants seemed excited to continue.

  2. I think the participants appreciated the interactivity. Instead of me describing and showing the tools, I broke them into groups and had them investigate the tools and then report back to the main group. Then, as each group presented, I augmented their remarks with examples from my presentation wiki.

  3. Group Brainstorming--after learning about a tool and seeing examples of it in use, we all brainstormed even more ways that we thought that the tool could be used.

Now I want to sit down and think about how I can further improve my presentation for next time, and polish it for its possible use at ISLMA. Overall, I think the workshop was well-received and I enjoyed sharing new ideas with such a receptive crowd. I'll follow up with each of the participants to see if they have further questions and if they use any of the information or tools in class. I'm glad I volunteered to present, and it's always valuable to go back and reflect!