Friday, April 22, 2011

FB + Teachers + Comments about school/parents/students = :P

Our last class and the extended discussion got me thinking about Facebook and educators. Clearly, teachers (and members of every other profession) have every right to be members of social networking sites. I can honestly say that having a Facebook account has been of benefit to me both personally (I am able to keep in good touch with distant friends and family) and professionally (I am able to network with colleagues and keep up with news and information that is pertinent to my interests). I don't believe I could give up Facebook at this point – I would literally be removing myself from an information environment that I have come to heavily rely on.

So why do so many teachers seem to get themselves into hot water with their Facebook accounts? A recent Google search yielded the following examples of teachers whose profiles have put their careers in serious jeopardy:

Girl's mom sues Chicago teacher over Facebook hairdo flap
http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-504083_162-20051341-504083.html

This teacher posted a photo of the hairstyle of one of her young students. According to reports, each of the child's braids contained Jolly Rancher candies at the end. The caption on her Facebook post read “Right! This was for picture day.”


Teacher suspended for Facebook post: called kids future criminals, parents say
http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Education/2011/0401/Teacher-suspended-for-Facebook-post-called-kids-future-criminals-parents-say

A first grade teacher in New Jersey posted about feeling like a warden and referred to her students as “future criminals” in her status updates.

Teachers Fired for Flirting on Facebook with Students
http://www.foxnews.com/scitech/2010/10/18/teachers-fired-flirting-facebook-students/

Three educators in New York are fired for having inappropriate contact with their students on Facebook – with at least one of those individuals bringing the interaction into real life by engaging in a sexual relationship with an 18 year old former student. In each case, inappropriate comments were made on the students' walls and photos as well as within the individuals' profiles.

Teacher Fired for Posting Picture of Herself Holding Beer on Facebook
http://www.gadailynews.com/news/61845-teacher-ashley-payne-fired-for-posting-picture-of-herself-holding-beer-on-facebook.html

In what is probably the most controversial teacher firing, Ashley Payne – a third grade teacher in Georgia – was fired after administrators received an anonymous email from a concerned parent who cited Ms. Payne's drinking and foul language on her Facebook profile as upsetting for her and her daughter. Ms. Payne is currently suing to be reinstated.

Teacher Loses Job After Commenting About Students, Parents on Facebook
http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/facebook-firing-teacher-loses-job-commenting-students-parents/story?id=11437248

Stressed out and on her third round of antibiotics, June Talvitie-Siple posted about not looking forward to another year at her school, called her students “germ bags”, and referred to the parents in her district as “snobby” and “arrogant”. Unfortuately, Ms. Talvitie-Siple did not make her Wall private and outraged parents called for her resignation. She acknowledged that her “stupid mistake” cost her her career.

ESU professor suspended for comments made on Facebook page
http://www.poconorecord.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20100226/NEWS/2260344/-1/NEWSLETTER100

Though this sociology professor believed that her profile was only visible to friends and family, Gloria Gadsden was allegedly turned in to university officials by a student after she wondered “"Does anyone know where I can find a very discrete hitman? Yes, it's been that kind of day.".

Teacher may lose job after derogatory comments about her students on Facebook
http://www.news-record.com/content/2010/02/15/article/teacher_may_lose_job_after_derogatory_comments_about_her_students_on_face

In North Carolina, Melissa Hussein was disciplined after she used her Facebook page to discuss the harassment her students were subjecting her to during school hours. Believing that their teacher was not Christian (her religious affliation – if she has one – is not noted in the article or on her Facebook page), students would sing “Jesus Loves Me” and read the Bible during her science classes. When a student left a Bible on her desk with a Christmas card inside (with added emphasis on “Christ” in the word “Christmas”), Hussein posted a status update that ellicted comments from friends that called her students “ignorant Southern rednecks”. She also indicated that the Bible incident would “not go unpunished”.

Charlotte teachers face action because of Facebook postings
http://www.heraldonline.com/2008/11/12/950992/charlotte-teachers-face-action.html

Another North Carolina teacher was fired when the school district's investigator (!) found that she “listed 'teaching chitlins in the ghetto of Charlotte' as one of her activities and drinking as one of her hobbies”. The school district acknowledged that they use an investigator who looks into accusations of inappropriate posts by both students and teachers.

******************

Every one of these teachers made a mistake that calls their own media literacy into question. I believe that by following five simple rules, most educators keep themselves and their jobs safe while still being able to participate in social networking.

1. Understand privacy settings and know how to use them.

In at least one of the cases above, the teacher did not understand that posts can be seen by all members of Facebook when the profile's Wall is not made private. Teachers with Facebook profiles should make every effort to make sure that their profiles are hidden from public view.

2. Control the content of your profile.

A “friend” tagged you in a picture and you're holding a beer?
Remove the tag.

A “friend” posted a response to one of the links you shared and used offensive language? Delete the comment.

A “friend” sends you a survey to find out “What sexy actress are you?”
If you must take the survey, don't click “Publish” when you get your results!

Be vigilent about the content that is shared on your Wall!

3. Beware of your “Friends”.

Two of the cases listed above involved anonymous tips about profiles that the owners thought were private. Is it possible that one of their own “friends” was actually a foe? Teachers should very carefully consider who they “friend” on Facebook – though most of us seemed to agree that “friending” current students was a bad idea, we might also want to consider whether or not to “friend” co-workers and parents (past, present, and future).

4. Resist the rant.

Four of the examples given were a result of a rant. If you have a bad day at work, consider sharing that with a spouse or trusted friend over dinner. You'll get the same benefit of having someone say “I hear ya!” without the electronic paper trail.

5. Assume that everyone can see what you're saying.

If all teachers in the example above had believed that everyone in the world could see their pictures, Walls, and information, they may have been more thoughtful before they allowed themselves (or others) to post on Facebook. Protect yourself by assuming that there is no protection.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

music and identity

I've been looking back over some of our earlier readings and trying to tie together all of the different kinds of literacies in the many contexts we've talked about all semester. In particular, I reread the introduction to Youth, Identity, and Digital Media by David Buckingham. His introduction ends with the following paragraph:

"Perhaps most importantly, a focus on identity requires us to pay close attention to the diverse ways in which media and technologies are used in everyday life, and their consequences both for individuals and for social groups. It entails viewing young people as significant social actors in their own right, as “beings,” and not simply as “becomings” who should be judged in terms of their projected futures. In our view, the needs of young people are not best served either by the superficial celebration or the exaggerated moral panics that often characterize this field. Understanding the role of digital media in the formation of youthful identities re- quires an approach that is clear sighted, unsentimental, and constructively critical" (p 19).

We haven't really talked about it since that first week, but I think that all of the literacies we've been discussing feed into how young people are forming and exploring their identities. In our quest for defining the various kinds of literacies, I think I've begun to see a common thread - literacy means the ability and drive to engage in conversation - whether it's in print, on a blog, through a podcast, or burned on a mix CD. When we're talking about media literacy, we're talking about the conversations we want young people to participate in, want them to explore with their own voices and minds, rather than simply accepting what is presented.

In particular, I've been thinking about musical literacy. In many ways, I'm more a part of the generation of digital natives than not. Middle school for me straddled the transition from tapes to CDs, and by the time I was in high school, burning mix CDs had become easy (and affordable). Now, almost everyone with a computer can build a digital library of songs, instantly look up song lyrics, download musical ringtones, and create their own music videos - not to mention the home recording capabilities of many computers. And when I think about musical literacy, I of course think of High Fidelity - the rules for making mix tapes, the endless Top 5 lists for different occasions, understanding how music shapes our lives and how we shape music around the moments in our lives. I think that the new media of computers - downloading MP3s, sharing music on LastFM or Pandora, small bands spreading their work through MySpace - has made musical literacy more complicated but also more accessible. Being a part of the musical conversation no longer requires physically proximity - to a big city where bands come to play, to a record store that stocks your favorite records, even to other people who are curious about the same music. Sites like Pandora and Pitchfork create a wide-reaching web where people can connect (via technology) with new music and people.

I imagine that teenagers (as long as there have been teenagers and music) have always used music to define themselves. As Hornby asks - "What came first, the music or the misery? People worry about kids playing with guns, or watching violent videos, that some sort of culture of violence will take them over. Nobody worries about kids listening to thousands, literally thousands of songs about heartbreak, rejection, pain, misery and loss. Did I listen to pop music because I was miserable? Or was I miserable because I listened to pop music?"

I'm not out to answer that question, but it is an interesting observation on how young people incorporate and evolve with music.

The mix CD, too, has become a marker of identity in much the same way that mix tapes were. What songs in what order? What do the songs say to the person you're giving it to? How did you decorate the CD and its case? I think that this literacy - understanding how music creates a conversation with itself and its listener, how combination and juxtaposition of music can create different effects, how multiple medias and technologies come into play. I don't know exactly how this literacy could be leveraged in the classroom but I feel like there is great potential to engage reluctant young people by getting them to use skills and tools they are already experimenting with to explore their academic as well as social identities.

First Draft of History?

There is no question of the important role social media networks like Twitter and Facebook played in the recent uprisings in the Middle East. Not only were social networks used to coordinate events but also to report reactions by various regimes. OR Books just published Tweets from Tahrir (April 7), a collection of tweets from the Egyptian revolution by those on the ground edited by Alex Nunns and Nadia Idle.

The first of its kind, Tweets from Tahrir tells the story of the Egyptian revolution by those directly involved. The editors received permission from the posters to use their tweets in the book, though it is believed the tweeters received no monetary compensation for their tweets. Never before in human history has the view of historical events from the average citizen been so available. As a history teacher, I recognize the intrinsic value of a book like Tweets from Tahrir. It tells an extraordinary story by ordinary people. It is precisely this popular perspective often lost from official recorded history. Social historians (historians who study the lives of average people & how they dealt with the big movements/events of their time) are incredibly creative at finding non-traditional sources to piece together ordinary life in ancient Rome or 16th Century Flanders. Social historians now have a treasure trove of information about any number of modern events thanks to social networking sites like Twitter. Of course posts used in Tweets from Tahrir had to be vetted as well as the tweeters themselves and it raises the question of tweet ownership. It raises a third, more historical question, for me: how is this new social media going to affect future history?

I do not think the tweeters in Tunisia, Egypt or Bahrain misrepresented their experience through their tweets. I am confident the editors of Tweets from Tahrir compiled tweets from reliable and verifiable posters—isn’t this what editors do? The speed at which Tweets from Tahrir was assembled is mind-boggling from the stand of historical perspective. The Egyptian revolution ‘began’ on 25 January 2011, culminating with Mubarak’s resignation on 11 February and who is to say if it is over. Tweets from Tahrir was released on 7 April. One of the editors, Alex Nunn, tweeted about the book, “1st draft [of] history?” The tweeters in the book did not make those tweets knowing they would be used just a few short months later in a book, certainly a book that will be a definitive one on the Egyptian revolution for decades to come. Now that Tweets from Tahrir is published (and depending on its reception) how will this change future tweeting? Will people tweet honestly about events (as much as one can from their viewpoint)? I believe the door has been opened for people to misrepresent facts/timelines/events through tweets in the hope/preparation their tweets are used for future books. Social media allows us to construct our identity through what we choose to disclose online. Will it now allow us to construct/shape/tweak historical events? Of course. It could also allow us to have a whole three-dimensional picture of historical events as never before. There is no doubt history now has a new dividing line: everything before social media and everything after it.

Awesome Classroom Project/Library Program: Students Create Virtual Field Trips

In the April 14th School Library Journal Newsletter I came across an article on a program/activity that I would love to try out. The article was about students creating videos for virtual field trips. The article focused on a student who created a video of her visit to The Windowfarms Project in New York City, where she learned about hydroponic gardening. She made a five minute video of her visit, in which she explains what hydroponic gardening is, gives a tour of the facility, and interviews the founder of the project. Her video, along with videos created by other students, can be found at www.meetmeatthecorner.org.

The site, Meet me at the Corner, is a great resource for teachers and librarians interested in doing this type of activity in their classroom or library. It hosts many submitted virtual field trips, and explains how to make a video of your own. Oddly enough, the videos on how to make a video of your own are created by kids as well, and are very easy and simple to follow. If you wanted to have your students create a video of their own the site would be great for showing them examples and walking them through the steps of making their own virtual field trips. For privacy reasons, I wouldn’t have my students post their videos to the site, only share them with the class.

Obviously, this type of project would require some major resources. You would need computer access, video cameras, and video editing software. And you would have to entrust students to taking the video camers outside of school, unless they already had their own at home to use. I think this type of project would work best with upper middle or high school students. You could have students work on their own, or in groups. You could plan a class field trip somewhere, say a museum, and have students create virtual field trips on different exhibits. If students had the travel resources, you could have them sign up for places to visit on their own, and have them create videos of their visit. I think students would really get into this type of project. It puts the control in their hands and gives them the opportunity to use their imagination and create. Also, it allows them to share their interests with the rest of the class, since they may be the ones determining the places they will visit.

If you don’t have the resources for your students to create virtual field trips, this site and the videos it houses could still be great resources for the classroom. Many of the virtual field trips could be used to supplement the curriculum. For instance, there is an interview with a meteorologist, an interview with a WWII veteran, a history of pizza, and a visit to the New York Hall of Science. There are even many book reviews and author interviews, all done by kids. If you don’t have the budget to take students on field trips, but wish you could, the virtual field trips on the site could allow you to introduce students to places and people they might not otherwise have an opporunity to see.

Article URL: http://www.schoollibraryjournal.com/slj/newslettersnewsletterbucketextrahelping2/890174-477/media_mix_student_videos_create.html.csp

gaming...i just can't get enough of it!

This class seemed to be a real big eye opener for me in regards to gaming in libraries. Our public library does not do games nights with the public, just with staff during after hours, so when I took another class and people were talking about gaming, I had no idea what they were talking about. We have board games and puzzles at our public library for children to do, and I thought that was the extent of what gaming was, boy was I wrong! Now it seems like I am continously finding articles on gaming in libraries and in schools. Recently I picked up the Scholastic Instructor magazine at our school and one of the articles was "Play to Learn." One public middle school, Quest to Learn, in New York City not only teaches kids how to play video games in class, but also how to design them. What a great experience! It seems anymore that we are expecting our children to sit in chairs for long hours to do math and reading, but we leave out the practical items that get them to think critically and put pieces together and to actually think. The article was very interesting in the fact that one professor of Arizona State University proclaimed that "colleges are still old-fashioned in the way they train new teachers, so many aren't entering the classroom ready to take up the remote controls." One principal even stated that "games aren't the cure-all, but they should be in a teacher's toolbox." The Quest to Learn school "uses games as a structure to look at how systems work-teaching subjects in new ways with new labels. Kids go to 'The Way Things Work' to take apart and put things together, learning science and math skills." And in "Sports for the Mind" students use "media arts, game design, and video storytelling." The cool part is that kids don't recieve traditonal grades, they move up in levels. I think this is a great tool to differientiate learning. Kids work at their own pace and can't move up unless they master the skill. Like the article said, gaming is "sort of like tricking them into learning." I'm not into putting kids in front of gaming system rather than having the teacher teach, but I think that if teachers are going to reach these kids and get them to learn, we are going to have to start changing our ways to do it. Teaching the way students learn, rather than just teaching the way we want to teach.

"Play to Learn." Instructor(2011): 64-66. Print.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Once More on Teen "Lunacy"

From Michael Chabon - an author who has written a lot about adolescence, and even a little bit about comic books - at the end of The Mysteries of Pittsburgh:

"When I think of that dizzy summer, that dull, stupid, lovely, dire summer, it seems that I ate my lunches, smelled another's skin, noticed a shade of yellow, even simply sat, with greater lust and hopefulness - and that I lusted with greater faith, hoped with greater abandon. The people I loved were celebrities, surrounded by rumor and fanfare; the places I sat with them, movie lots and monuments. No doubt all of this is not true remembrance but the ruinous work of nostalgia, which obliterates the past, and no doubt, as usual, I have exaggerated everything."

How do we keep that lust for life and unabashed hopefulness alive? Must it always become "ruinous nostalgia"?

Monday, April 18, 2011

Graphic Story Telling in the Classroom

Last week I decided to put our class discussion on graphic literacy into practice and assigned my creative writing students to write and design a 12 panel comic strip. They were allowed to hand-draw them or use an online generator (I suggested www.stripgenerator.com and www.pixton.com). The results proved that graphic story telling is an advanced skill, but still fun for all who attempt.

The twenty students in the class are all seniors and had to have an A or B in junior English to take this class. We had already studied and wrote non-fiction essays and short stories, and I purposely waited until after the short story unit to give this assignment. I wanted them to have a full understanding of how to develop plot structure, characterization, setting, and dialog before they attempted to write a comic strip in which all of those elements would have to be detailed in limited space. I passed out the assignment guidelines towards the end of the class period and then gave them opportunity to ask questions and brainstorm. They then had two full hours in the computer lab the following days to complete the comic that had to be emailed to me by the third day.

To say the kids had a blast would be an understatement. For the first time all semester, none of them procrastinated or tried to work on other assignments. Seventeen of the students opted to use Pixton, two used Strip Generator, and one drew her own (with fabulous results). They quickly figured out how to create their panels and characters while I answered the few questions that they had. They also were constantly checking out each other’s work and offering suggestions or showing different techniques of how to manipulate the characters’ movements or props. Then on the day they were due, we had a fun hour of presenting the comics to the class.

As I watched them work and graded their final projects, I saw as I had predicted that the ones who were better story writers were better comic strip writers. Those who struggle with plot development and characterization had nonsensical stories and flat characters. However, my more skilled writers managed to convey a variety of emotions and full plots. Two students’ work did catch my eye. One girl is a fantastic writer, however, she is lazy and her stories always end up lacking in their resolution because she ends them so abruptly. The boy is also a great writer, but he’s a slow starter who always ends up with overdrawn plots that are turned in a day or two late. They turned in two of the best comic strips in the class and I think they both benefited from the 12 panel restriction. She had to keep the story going until its resolution in the 12th panel while he had to keep his story focused to also reach its resolution.

In my opinion, the assignment didn’t help struggling writers by giving them a new format for storytelling. However, it did present an exciting new challenge for the entire class that they all enjoyed and strongly recommended that I assign to future classes.

One final note for anyone planning on doing this assignment—Pixton charges for school accounts. The students can create “Pixton for Fun” accounts on their own, but if they are under 18, they have to put in the email address of a parent, who is then e-mailed for approval.