Monday, May 2, 2011

Your Digital Legacy

Note: I originally posted this as a comment on another post, but then wasn't sure if it would be seen and counted since it was a response, not a new post. My apologies for posting it twice.

I actually read an article about this in the New York Times Magazine a couple of months ago (http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/09/magazine/09Immortality-t.html?_r=1&scp=1&sq=your%20immortal%20cybersoul&st=cse) and found it quite interesting, to say the least. The article also referenced the book you talked about.

I had never thought at all about your digital legacy and what would happen to it after you die. It is definitely an interesting question and brings up lots of issues.

The article mentions that estimates are that 375,000 facebook users die each year. I can only assume that as more and more people join facebook that the number will likely rise. Lots of questions arise about what happens to your content, who can access it, etc. In one case, the article talks about one family who sued Yahoo in an effort to get their son's email password after he was killed in Iraq. Yahoo refused, but was eventually ordered by the court to turn a cd with all his emails in it to the family. As you can see, the digital age and post mortem digital world is creating a new legal field. It makes me wonder if people should add a clause to their will bequeathing digital access to a particular beneficiary. Apparently, in addition to bank account information and safe deposit keys, people should also be providing passwords as part of their estate planning process.

The article also talked a lot about a particular prolific blogger and writer who died suddenly at the age of 34. His parents not only had to sort through his personal possessions, but also his digital life. His parents, who did not even own a computer at that point, then had to determine how/if to preserve his online self, in a sense. They also talked about how they had little idea about his blogs and how much they learned about their son after he was gone. It's an interesting thing to think about: how much would your friends and family learn about you after you're gone by looking at your computer?

Of course, in the American way, those with an entrepreneurial spirit have stepped up to make some money. One site DeathSwitch.com is discussing creating a site to send messages to loved ones after you have died. Of course, these could be sentimental messages or those of a more practical matter, like passwords, etc. Other services have already been created to act as digital safe deposit boxes.

The article definitely made me think more about the digital elements of estates. For example, if you had some sort of web business, that could be a valuable asset even though there may be no true "physical" elements of that asset.

Of course, if we do indeed attempt to preserve these "digital legacies" we also create a huge mass of digital information, much of which might be unworthy of preserving. For example, if a family member dies, part of the process is cleaning out their stuff and trying to separate between the valuable and the "other." If we are looking at digital information, that task may be more difficult. Definitely lots to think about.

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Making Videos More Meaningful: Finding a Better Alternative for Some of the Most Frequently Read Texts

Whether in the English classroom or a librarian’s book club, I think it might be the go-to activity after reading a book: watch the movie after reading the book. Unfortunately, this really isn’t the best way to facilitate discussion. If the movie is virtually the exact same as the literature, students don’t have as rich of a conversation because there are no new themes, characterization, or plot development. If a librarian or teacher chooses films that have similar themes but different plots or plots that have been transported to a different time era, students can make more interesting and thoughtful connections. Here are some discussion question examples I’ve created for The Great Gatsby, Taming of the Shrew, and Hamlet when paired with less obvious film choices.

The Great Gatsby and Chicago

Instead of watching Robert Redford (even if it is a great film), Chicago could be a great introduction to the time period and themes of the novel.

  1. How could the song “All That Jazz” be representative of America in the 20’s?
  2. Describe the differences between the words of the song about Billy and his true character. How does the film show this? Where do we see this kind of duplicity in The Great Gatsby?
  3. Describe Roxie’s back story. How does she change herself? Why? Explain how someone had a parallel experience in The Great Gatsby.
  4. Why do they blame “liquor and jazz” for Roxie’s crime? What does this tell us about the 20’s? Are these problems in The Great Gatsby? Why or why not?
  5. How does fashion play a role in both this book and film?
  6. Describe common themes in both the book and film. How do they translate from the different forms of media?

Taming of the Shrew and Ten Things I Hate About You

Ten Things I Hate About You was inspired by this complicated Shakespearian play. Watching this film can make the identity switching and complicated interwoven plots much more manageable for students.

  1. Describe how the following ideas are in both the film and play: Padua, Verona, Stratford, and the works’ titles.
  2. What commentary could this movie be making about teen social classes? How does this connect to Taming of the Shrew? (Hint: Are all the characters in the same economic class? Are they treated differently because of this?)
  3. Do the movie and play have different ideas about gender roles? Explain.
  4. Discuss the theme of sibling rivalry in both the play and movie.
  5. Bianca appears to be a dynamic character in both the play and the movie. Does she change in the same way in both? Explain.
  6. Connect the following movie characters to who they connect to in the play: Kat, Walter, Bianca, Patrick, Cameron, Joey, and Michael. How are they similar and different?
  7. How does the modern setting of the movie change the story and characters?
  8. How is watching a film different from reading/watching a play?

Hamlet and Lion King

Although created for very different audiences, these two texts have similar themes and characters.

  1. Explain how the theme of revenge plays out in both the play and the movie.
  2. Explain how the theme of hesitation plays out in both the play and the movie.
  3. Explain how the theme of family conflict plays out in both the play and the movie.
  4. Explain how the theme of power plays out in both the play and the movie.
  5. Explain how the theme of responsibility plays out in both the play and the movie.
  6. How does the very adult-centric play translate to a children’s film?
  7. Describe the connections between the major characters of the play and film.
  8. How is watching a film different from reading/watching a play?


The News Travels Quickly: Osama bin Laden's Death...in 30 minutes

As I sit here waiting for President Obama's unplanned address, I can't help but think of the power of social media and putting news into the hands of the people.

I've been on Facebook pretty much all night because I'm multi-tasking and my TV service happens to be out. If not for Facebook (I don't use Twitter), I doubt I would know that any of this is happening. Before CNN even broke the story, three of my Facebook friends had already posted the news via Fox News. Seriously? They beat CNN! I know because I checked CNN right after looking at Fox. If that's not impressive, I don't know what is.

In response to this, one of my Facebook friends said, "Moments like this make me appreciate the impact and potential of social media -- Twitter is amazing right now." Another friend probably put it best, though, when she said, "I get all of my news updates from Facebook. What more do you really need?" And that's a good question!

Well, I think we do still need the news outlets. After finding out that bin Laden was dead, I (and many like me I presume) went straight to the actual news source. It's something we've talked about over and over again--in this day, the news finds us...we don't find the news.

However, it's really a recursive process that's going on here. We catch wind of something from social media, go to the news source to learn more, post about it ourselves on Facebook (or Twitter), discuss it on Facebook, read more, post again, etc.--and the great thing is that this happens so quickly! In a matter of 30 minutes, I found out about this, read a handful of articles on two different news websites, read a little about bin Laden, posted on Facebook, and wrote this blog post. I'm also geared up to watch the address on my computer since, as I mentioned, my TV service is out!

So is social media powerful? Yep, I think so. And is it valuable? Sure is.

World of Story-Craft

I grew up in a simpler time. A time when video games involved shooting a gun at small ducks flying across my television screen as a large, brown dog occasionally popped up to laugh at me. There was no detailed plot behind the game, nor were there complex characters

So much has changed in video games since my childhood of the late 1980’s even if I haven’t been feverishly playing them to experience their evolution. As we have talked and read about video games this semester, I have developed a greater appreciation of gamers’ love of games, and this week’s article “Using Video Games as Bait to Hook Readers” by Motoko Rich helped me see a greater benefit of the popular complex games as they can be a hybrid of multiple types of literacy.

But are these games really encouraging reading? Rich even mentions in his article that most of the 30 boys at a gaming tournament, “did not read much and rarely checked out books” (n.pag.) This isn’t stopping video game companies and libraries from connecting gamers to books as is evident by the new games such as “The Maze of Bones” and “Brisingr,” both of which are connected to published series. And of course there is always the fact that video games require some reading, whether it is instructions, plot summary, character dialog, or even extras to the game like blog posts and guides (n. pag.). The most appealing games seem to be the most complex ones, and writer and college professor James Parini predicts that “… in the next 10 or 20 years, video games are creating fictional universes which are every bit as complex as the world of fiction of Dickens or Dostoevsky” (n.pag.).

It is that complex gaming world that I think would be most beneficial to improving literacy in young gamers. My playing "Duck Hunt" helped my aim, but not much else. The games today build visual literacy as gamers play their way through their three-dimensional worlds, improve digital literacy as they learn the game play, and teach them graphic literacy through the stories they see. I’d always assumed the stories would have to have some sort of complexity in order to make them interesting and challenging, but never would have realized how much so without my former student, Cole. I taught Cole last year for freshmen English and always looked forward to his essays that were written with a sophistication and voice that greatly surpassed his peers. He is a quite, shy kid with a sharp wit, and although I don’t have him in class anymore, he stops by my room several times a week to talk about a story he is writing. After several weeks of brief discussions and a glance at his outline, Cole presented me with a five act story and asked if I could edit it and offer him any notes for improvement. The plot was incredibly intricate with a multitude of characters (some of which double-cross each other) and settings. Its climax was heart-breaking as the hero realized his arch-enemy’s minion, “The Man in the Mask,” was actually his own brother, who he would have to kill to save their world.

When I saw Cole the next day, I told him how much I enjoyed it and after offering a few suggestions, asked what his plans were for the story when he finished it. He looked at me as if I was clueless and responded, “It’s going to be a video game.”

Cole is the perfect product of his video game generation. He has the understanding of the necessary components of a successful video game, including a compelling story, and the ability to create such a story. As he shows me the maps and character mock-ups that he’s drawing, I am learning even more about games, and seeing first-hand Motoko Rich’s point that some of the new projects that pair books with video games “may push creative boundaries, helping to extend storytelling beyond the traditional covers of a book” (n.pag.). Even if games don’t ultimately push players to be readers, it’s pretty cool to watch a teenager combine his love of writing with his love of gaming with awesome results.

Rich, Motoko. “Using Video Games as Bait to Hook Readers.” The New York Times. 6 Oct. 2008. Web. 28 Apr. 2011.

The Power of Simple Print and Visual Media

“Want Respect? VOTE Tuesday April 5 2011” (sic) was all the sign said in large black letters on a white background yet they signaled a political revolution of sorts in the City of Champaign this month. A few days before the April municipal elections, these signs (about 200 of them according to the Champaign News Gazette) suddenly appeared all over Champaign’s north end, which is historically predominantly African American. I noticed them on nearly every corner as I drove up Prospect, one of the busier thoroughfares in Champaign.

The signs obviously did not endorse a particular candidate or party (although Champaign’s municipal elections are technically non-partisan). However, it is a good example of how a simple message can have a much deeper meaning for many. My main question was who paid for them and put them up.

If you follow local politics in Champaign at all, you would know that there has historically been a lot of animosity between the City of Champaign (mostly the police department) and the black community. This issue really came to a head sometime in the fall of 2009 when a young teenage African American male was shot and killed by a Champaign police officer while he and the chief of police were responding to a call of a possible burglary in progress. It was a real tragedy for everyone concerned and really drove an even deeper wedge between the police department and the black community.

So, what does this have to with a political yard sign a year and a half later? At the time of the shooting, the current mayor, himself a long-retired Champaign police officer himself, was perceived as being less than sympathetic toward the victim and his family. The City did make an effort to have some dialogue with members of the community, old and young. I was asked to facilitate a small group session at a large gathering discussing police-community relations at one point.

After serving as mayor for twelve years and running unopposed for the previous two elections, this time he was faced with a completely unknown challenger who had never been much involved in the community at all. Most people that followed such things assumed that the incumbent was an absolute shoe-in. It was widely assumed that the incumbent would likely not fare well in the north end precincts, but the voter turnout was typically fairly low anyway in those precincts.

Enter the signs……… Now that you know a little bit of history of the community and a very small snippet of issues facing the community, you probably have a better idea of the sign’s meaning and why they may have made a big difference in the election outcome. When all was said and done, the incumbent lost by a relatively small margin (about 250 or fewer votes) and the political newcomer will take office this week. The turnout in the north end precincts was much higher than usual and may well have made the difference in the election. (To be fair, there were other issues with the incumbent being perceived as being anti-labor and is also a birther and Tea Partier.)

The other issue that the signs may have been raising awareness for (again, without explicitly saying it) was the fact that there was an African American candidate on the ballot for the Champaign School Board, a school district that is 35% African American and has an all-white school board. The issues between the school district and the black community are so extensive that a book could be written. Literally. That candidate won too, by the way.

My question about where the signs came from and who paid for them was answered a few days after the election in the Champaign News Gazette. I tried in vain for about a half hour to find the article online and never could find it. It was part of their editorial page, as I recall, so they may not have posted it. Anyway, the signs were bought and distributed by a small group of leaders and business people within Champaign’s black community who were somewhat fed up with the way the mayor had responded to issues that affected the black community. Even though the sign, “Want Respect? VOTE Tuesday April 5 2011," did not say who to vote for or not vote for, the message was clear for many voters.

So, how does this long-winded account relate to media literacy? Obviously no one will ever really know to what extent the yard signs made a difference, but I am certain that they were effective in ensuring that people knew about the election. What struck me, among other things, was that in this media-filled world of online ads, social networking, television and radio and a variety of other outlets, the good old-fashioned yard sign with a simple and succinct message may well have carried the day, or at least helped carry it.

Put Understanding First

The article posted in our assignment for last week, or maybe the week before, titled "Educational Leadership: Reshaping High Schools: Put Understanding First," really hit the educational spot for me. Despite that it was focused towards teachers in high school, I think anyone who teaches would find the information in it very valuable. Being a Prek through 1st grade teacher-librarian, I was never given a curriculum to help me know what to teach my students, or how to teach library. In my first year, I looked at the Illinois Standards as a guideline, discussed with the other elementary librarian what her expectations were of students entering second grade and looked at other websites for other school librarians. Through all of my research and in my third year of teaching, I have finally set a curriculum for my kindergarten students. It's not perfect, but I tried to use my first two years as guide on what sequence of introducing concepts that worked and where I needed to move things, and I think it is finally set in stone. I'm now working on first grade, which will probably take me another two years, and then three more curriculums for 3, 4 and 5 year olds. Like a teacher, I know what I want my students to learn, and now my only problem is how to teach it so they understand it and can apply it to various settings. Many teachers have stated that this is the biggest problem in education, students not able to transfer and use skills used in one setting to another. And this is something that I do not want. I want my students to be able to use the skills I teach them in any setting and with different people, and with different wording. So I try very hard to phrase things in different ways. Ask questions in reverse. For example, kindergarten students know that the spine holds the book together, but I also want them to be able to answer, "what holds a book together?" The article pointed out that "out-of-context learning of skills is arguably one of the greatest weaknesses of the secondary curriculum," but it is also a problem in the elementary and primary level as well. It also said, "that if we don't give students sufficient ongoing opportunities to puzzle over genuine problems, make meaning of their learning, and apply content in various contents, then long-term retention and effective performance are unlikely, and high schools will have failed to achieve their purpose." I try to achieve this concept every year with the library scavenger that I started last year with the first graders. I give pairs of students five questions and they must use the skills I have taught them to locate and find books either using the information freely or using the information with OPAC. The questions are very basic and usually have other information that they must right down. For example, I would give them the title of a book. They would have to search OPAC to find the call number, write down the call number and then find the book on shelf and tell me the author, illustrator, copyright date, publisher and title. Some students who are at the higher level, know they can find most of this information on the OPAC screen, but not all students are at that level of thinking. In either case, they find the information, write it down and go to the next one. Sometimes I give them the title and call number and they have to do the same thing. It is a lot of fun, the library gets noisy and the kids really enjoy it. It also lets me know where I need to improve what I am teaching if they are not able to answer certain questions or find the information. It is a learning experience for all of us. Every situation in the library is a learning situation. I had one student ask, why she just couldn't have a shelf marker and go to a shelf and pick out a book, but I don't make it that easy. I give them a three letter call number and they must match that call number to a call number on a book. They may not know it, but they are learning how a library is laid out and by the end of the year, I would say over 95% of my kindergarten students can find their call number with no assistance and by the end of first grade I would say very close to 100% can find an easy fiction call number with no help, or hints. It is a skill I feel they can use for their rest of their lives, whether finding a word in the dictionary or looking for a book on the shelf. I try to make all the skills I teach them skills that they will need later in life. I'm not perfect, and I am always striving to be a better teacher and helping students who are just not getting new ways to understand.

Wordless Books?

I am in a mixed married. I am a visual learner partnered with a kinesthetic learner. While this has at times produced some entertaining situations, I must say it has produced one awesome kid. She gets all kinds of great experiences; busting up concrete in the backyard with rock hammer and reading feminist graphic novels all in the same day. While her dad is her favorite let’s-figure-out-how-this-works buddy, when she wants to quietly immerse herself in books, I am her go-to girl. With a bachelor’s in acting (no joke), I have a pleasant reading voice and use it in a variety of ways to make the story interesting. At bedtime stories, I rock.

Which is why stories without print have always flummoxed me. While I find them very interesting and usually beautifully illustrated, what the heck am I supposed to do as the reader to a four year-old? In general, I have stayed away from choosing wordless books for our child. My partner, however, greatly enjoys them and usually picks out a few on their excursions to the library. Lately, I have been more comfortable choosing wordless books for us to read together and realize there is a lot for me to do as her reader-we read the pictures, discuss the story, ask questions and try to devise answers. I have been so focused on reading words to her, I begin to fear I may have neglected her other literacies.

A lovely list of some wordless books for all ages. I would highly recommend The Arrival by Shaun Tan. The story of an immigrant trying to find his way in a strange land while desperately missing his family, it could be a perfect companion book for a unit on immigration at any grade level. I grabbed it in my school library while I was waiting to meet with an insurance agent. I was immediately enthralled.